Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brennan Wierzba's avatar

The next great division will be between those who wish to live as creatures and those who wish to live as machines. -Wendell Berry ‘life is a miracle’

Expand full comment
Eric's avatar

Ah, yes. The classic “AI is ruining everything” chorus—sung in unison by those who have neither used it deeply nor interrogated their own resistance to it. But here you are, happily marching to the beat of a different drum, not only using AI but actually enjoying the experience. How scandalous.

Of course, the skeptics would say you’re just rationalizing your own descent into creative laziness. That AI hasn’t “unlocked” anything—it’s just made you more comfortable outsourcing the hard part of thinking. Isn’t struggle supposed to be part of the process? Shouldn’t the blank page terrify you a little? After all, if AI can neatly package your thoughts without the slow-burn agony of writing, what separates the real thinkers from the copy-paste crowd? If anyone with a keyboard and an internet connection can suddenly express themselves with clarity, does that diminish the craft? The skeptics might argue that ease comes at the cost of depth—that by skipping the grind, you’re skipping the growth.

Your closing question—“Or is this writing?”—lands like a well-placed punch. Because it forces the reader to ask: if AI helps articulate your thoughts, organize your ideas, and refine your work, then what, exactly, is it stealing? And if the only thing AI is taking away is the hesitation, the second-guessing, the creative paralysis—then maybe the real fear isn’t that AI is making us dumber.

Maybe it’s making us move.

Well played.

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts